Noticias
Why CPR Training Alone Did Not Improve Survival, And What An AED Program Needs Instead
Key Takeaway
The RACE-CARS trial trained more than 200,000 people in CPR across 60 North Carolina counties over five years, and survival after cardiac arrest did not improve. The figure that did not move is the one facility managers control: how often a defibrillator reached the patient before EMS. Here is what the trial found and what a managed AED program needs beyond a training record.
Short answer: RACE-CARS, a five-year randomized trial across 60 North Carolina counties, trained 201,586 people in CPR and trained 911 dispatchers to coach callers. Survival with good brain function was about 9% in counties with the program and 9.4% in counties without it, a difference that was not statistically significant. Defibrillation before EMS arrival did not rise either: 13.5% with the program and 15.3% without. For anyone who manages a building, the lesson is that a trained workforce needs a reachable, ready AED to work with, and that part is a program decision, not a training decision.
On November 8, 2026, researchers presented the primary results of the RACE-CARS trial at the American Heart Association's Scientific Sessions in Chicago, and the full manuscript was published the same day in the New England Journal of Medicine. It is one of the most ambitious community cardiac arrest efforts ever put through a randomized trial, and its headline result is a sobering one.
This article walks through what the trial tested, what it found, and what it suggests for the people who own AEDs: safety managers, facilities directors, HR leaders, school administrators and anyone else whose name ends up on the device.
What RACE-CARS Set Out To Test
RACE-CARS, short for Randomized Cluster Evaluation of Cardiac Arrest Systems, ran from July 2021 through June 2026. Researchers randomly assigned 31 North Carolina counties to receive a comprehensive cardiac arrest education program, while 29 counties continued with their existing practices. Together the 60 counties cover about 8.5 million residents, close to 80% of the state's population, across urban and rural areas.
The program had two parts. A community part delivered free CPR training through schools, workplaces, county government and community organizations. An EMS part trained 911 dispatchers to recognize cardiac arrest quickly and guide callers through CPR, and strengthened first-responder efforts, including more use of defibrillation before EMS arrived.
The scale is what makes the result hard to set aside. Community partners ran 5,724 training events and reached 201,586 people. The trial followed 22,459 adults who had a cardiac arrest outside a hospital, using the national CARES registry to track outcomes.
What The Trial Found
The primary outcome was survival to hospital discharge with favorable brain function. According to the American Heart Association's summary of the results:
- Survival: about 9% in program counties and 9.4% in comparison counties. The difference was not statistically significant.
- Bystander CPR: 44.8% in program counties and 42.3% in comparison counties. In an exploratory look at the final year, people in program counties had 33% higher odds of receiving bystander CPR, which the investigators read as a sign that sustained outreach may take longer to show up in survival.
- Defibrillation before EMS: 13.5% of arrests in program counties and 15.3% in comparison counties.
The trial also distributed 405 defibrillators to the 31 program counties. Of those counties, 87% deployed the devices, 63% placed some in publicly accessible locations, and 60% put devices with first responders such as fire departments and law enforcement.
The investigators noted real-world limits: counties implemented the program unevenly, much of the data on training was self-reported, 911 centers faced staffing turnover, and both the COVID-19 pandemic and Hurricane Helene disrupted the work. Those caveats matter. They also describe the conditions any real organization operates under.
The Number Facility Managers Should Look At
Training is necessary. Nothing in this trial argues for less of it, and the researchers' own message to the public remains to learn CPR, call 911 and follow the dispatcher. But one figure deserves particular attention from anyone responsible for a building: how often a defibrillator was used before EMS arrived. Five years of sustained, community-wide effort did not raise it.
A trained bystander can only use an AED that they can find, reach and open. In practice, that depends on things a CPR class does not cover:
- Location. Is the device within a short round trip of where people actually are, including the far end of the property, upper floors, outbuildings and parking areas?
- Access. Is it reachable at the hours the building is in use, or does it sit behind an office door that locks at 5 p.m.?
- Signage. Would someone who has never been in the building find it in a hurry?
- Readiness. Are the pads and battery within their expiration dates, and is the status indicator showing ready?
- Awareness. Does the person on shift tonight know where it is, and is the device registered so a 911 dispatcher can point a caller to it?
Every one of those is a decision someone at the facility makes or fails to make. That is the part of the chain of survival an organization actually owns.
What A Training Record Does Not Tell You
A current training roster is easy to show an auditor. It says nothing about whether the AED it pairs with is usable. A short self-audit, which a facilities manager can usually finish in an afternoon, closes that gap:
- List every AED you own, with its make, model, serial number and exact placement.
- Walk from the farthest point of each area to the nearest AED and time it. Our three-minute walk test explains how.
- Check each device's status indicator and record the pad and battery expiration dates.
- Confirm each device can be reached without a key during the hours the space is used.
- Ask two people on different shifts where the nearest AED is, without warning them first.
- Confirm each device is registered with your local 911 center or registry. See how AED registration connects your device to 911.
The Five Elements Of A Managed AED Program
Organizations that keep AEDs ready year after year tend to treat them as a program rather than a purchase. The program has five parts:
- Inventory and location mapping. One list, one owner, and a map that shows where every device is and what area it covers.
- Readiness checks. A routine inspection on a set schedule, following the manufacturer's instructions for your model, with the result written down.
- Pad and battery lifecycle. Expiration dates tracked in advance so replacements arrive before they are needed, not after.
- Registration and notification. Each device registered with the local 911 center or AED registry, and updated when a device moves. Some states, including Georgia under its Mason Sells AED Coordination Act, now require it.
- Documented response roles. A written plan that names who calls 911, who retrieves the AED and who meets EMS, checked against who is actually on site each shift.
What To Do In The Next 30 Days
Start with the inventory and the walk test. Those two steps surface most gaps on their own: a device in the wrong place, a unit behind a locked door, a pad set that expired last spring. Then put the readiness check on a recurring calendar and assign it to a role rather than a person, so it survives turnover.
If you would like a second set of eyes on an existing program, we review AED programs every day and have since 2003. AEDs are our only business. Call us at 888-541-2337 and tell us how many devices you have and where they are.
Related Reading
- The Three-Minute Walk Test: How To Check AED Access At Courts, Parks And Recreation Centers
- Is Your AED On The Map? How AED Registration Connects Your Device To 911
- AED Training For Employees: What Good Preparedness Actually Looks Like
Sources
- American Heart Association Newsroom, "Community CPR and EMS intervention program did not increase survival after cardiac arrest," November 8, 2026: newsroom.heart.org
- STAT News, "Survival after sudden cardiac arrest didn't improve despite training bystanders, emergency responders," November 8, 2026: statnews.com
- ClinicalTrials.gov, RACE-CARS (NCT04660526): clinicaltrials.gov
This article summarizes published research for general information and is not medical or legal advice. Follow the manufacturer's instructions for your specific AED, and make sure the people expected to use it have current training.
Next Step
Ready To Equip Your Location?
Compare AEDs from six authorized brands, or find the pads and battery for the unit you already own.


